'nocebo' effect: how informed consent can cause unnecessary harm in trials
The requirement of informed consent means that it is an ethical requirement to warn patients about risks of taking part in clinical trials. But recent research shows that the way in which patients are told about these risks can actually cause harm.
Dr Jeremy Howick, Director of the Oxford Empathy Programme, Faculty of Philosophy, and study author, says: 'Sometimes when we warn patients about negative side effects in a scary way it actually causes the negative side effect - a "nocebo effect".'
A mega-study cited in the paper found that half of the 250,000 patients who took placebo pills (like sugar pills) in clinical trials reported some negative side effects (like pain or nausea but also more serious things). Current requirements for taking informed consent force ethics committees to focus on talking a lot about trial harms. This is understandable from a medico-legal perspective.
Researchers are concerned about 'outlier' cases where a patient might say that they were not sufficiently well informed about a potential harm which they experienced. But talking about harms in the wrong way can cause its own harm. This study shows that ethics committees need to take these 'nocebo' harms seriously.
There are emerging ways to share risks with patients without causing unnecessary nocebo effects. Foremost among these is positive framing.
Dr Howick says: 'You can tell a patient, "10% of the people who take this drug have a negative side-effect", or you can say, "90% of the people don't have any negative side-effects". In both cases the information is the same, but the first way leads to more reported side-effects.
'Ethics committees need to take the reality of nocebo effects into account, and balance the need to inform patients with the need to inform them the right way.'
Read the full paper in the Journal of Medical Ethics: ' Unethical informed consent caused by overlooking poorly measured nocebo effects.'
More than 1.4 million young women over a six-year period received pelvic exams or Pap smears they might not have needed, a new national study published in the peer-reviewed medical journal JAMA Internal Medicine estimates — suggesting that doctors, ...
A leading international human rights group has rebuked the Australian government for police raids on the media, saying the country's national security laws were having a "chilling effect" on journalists and their sources. Human Rights Watch has said in its ...
Derrick Henry. Deshaun Watson. Adam Thielen. Russell Wilson. What the Wildcard round proved is that if you have a player that can dominate no matter the situation or surroundings, you have a chance. The San Francisco 49ers have more than a chance ...
The number of people who are 80-years-old and older is on the rise, and will account for nearly 10 percent of the whole U.S. population by 2050. Since the lifetime chance for developing high blood pressure is at least 70 percent by age 80, more and more ...
A study found that many young women undergo pelvic examinations and Pap tests, even though current guidelines suggest they may not be necessary.
More News in research
Study finds evidence to suggest statins could lower risk of ovarian cancer. Charity-funded research might have unlocked a new weapon in the fight against ovarian cancer. A new study has found evidence to suggest that women
The market report envelopes an all-in information of the global Musical Instrument Amplifier market and the nature of the market growth over the foreseeable period. The report provides a comprehensive elaboration of the
The region's leading universities, the GW4 Alliance, together with the Met Office, Hewlett Packard Enterprise (HPE), and partners, have been awarded £4.1 million by the Engineering and Physical Sciences Research Council
"Digital Experience Platform Market" Report will provide important aspects with overall outlook of the market worldwide, According to Adroit Market Research. The term "digital experience platform" sounds like a remedy for marketers, a simple resolution